Retired IRS Officer D.P. Haokip Rejects Timothy Zimik’s Open Letter, Urges Govt To Uphold Peace Framework And Equal Justice In Manipur

Retired IRS Officer D.P. Haokip Rejects Timothy Zimik’s Open Letter, Urges Govt To Uphold Peace Framework And Equal Justice In Manipur

Songpi: A retired officer of the Indian Revenue Service, D.P. Haokip, has issued a detailed rejoinder to an open letter written by another retired IRS officer, K. Timothy Zimik, on the situation in Manipur. In the letter dated November 18, 2026, addressed to Chief Minister Yumnam Khemchand and Governor Ajay Kumar Bhalla, Haokip said he was writing to place what he described as the truth on record. He said Zimik’s letter was not a plea for peace but, in his view, a communal charge-sheet against an entire people. He said he rejected it in full.

Haokip, who identifies himself as a resident of K. Salbung, Tuibong Sub-Division in Churachandpur district, said Zimik’s letter brands Kukis as foreigners and terrorists, demands military operations against Kuki villages, demands abrogation of a peace agreement, and accuses the Government of India and its security forces of conspiracy. Haokip argued that such claims, if acted upon, would deepen division and push Manipur further away from peace. He appealed to the state and central leadership to listen to the Constitution, protect all citizens equally, and punish the guilty, whoever they are, rather than punish an entire community.

The rejoinder is structured as a point-by-point response to Zimik’s letter. Haokip takes up issues raised in the original letter, including history, disarmament and village raids, the description of recent attacks, the Suspension of Operations (SoO) agreement, the Mt. Sinai camp, the role of the Assam Rifles and the Government of India, and the question of illegal immigration. On each point, he presents a counter-argument and calls for investigation, due process and verification instead of collective blame. The letter ends with seven specific demands and a conclusion urging peace through truth, equal justice and dialogue.

On history, Haokip responded to Zimik’s claim that Kuki history is replete with massacres of innocent Nagas and that Kukis started the Kuki-Meitei and Kuki-Naga wars. Haokip said this was false. He said Kukis are an indigenous Scheduled Tribe people of Manipur, recognised by the Constitution, with ancestral villages, chieftainship and history in the hills for centuries. He said they are not foreigners. He added that all communities in Manipur have suffered, and that history written as if one community is always the aggressor and the other always innocent is not history but propaganda.

Haokip also addressed the killing of four Tangkhul Naga civilians at New Heaven, NH-202, on November 13, 2026. He said he condemned the killing unequivocally and that every innocent killing must be condemned. At the same time, he said condemnation requires investigation, not communal accusation. He said Zimik had produced no FIR, no investigation report, no forensic evidence and no court finding in support of his attribution of blame. Haokip demanded an independent investigation into that ambush and punishment of the real culprits, whoever they are. He said an accusation without proof is not proof.

On disarmament and the demand for raids on villages, Haokip described this as the most dangerous part of Zimik’s letter. According to Haokip, Zimik demanded disarmament of Kukis on the ground that the majority of Kukis are fully armed and are terrorists, declared a list of villages – Mollen, Tongshum, Chingphei, Molnom, Lamlai, Chingphai, Yaolol, Mongkot Chepu, Shangkai, Zalengbung, Shongmun, Lepilen, Laphugrat, Pashong, Shongphel and Mullam – as terrorist centres, and demanded simultaneous military combing operations in all of them. Haokip said this was effectively a demand for military operations against civilian Kuki villages.

Haokip said these are villages where families live, children study, and churches stand. He argued that to publish a list of villages and demand they be raided is to put a target on innocent villagers. He said the claim that the majority of Kukis are terrorists is hate speech. He described the Kuki people as farmers, pastors, teachers, students, mothers, elders and children. He said to brand lakhs of people as terrorists is collective punishment by language. He said if Zimik has evidence against any individual, he should name that individual and file an FIR, but he has no right to demand that an entire community be disarmed and hunted.

On the principle of disarmament, Haokip said that if disarmament is to mean anything, it must be universal, lawful and applicable to all armed groups of all communities, under due process. He said one-sided, communal disarmament is not justice. He said it is persecution. He argued that selective action based on a communal list would not bring security, but would create fear, resentment and further alienation. He urged the government not to act on the basis of a communal list prepared by any community leader.

On the description of recent attacks, Haokip responded to Zimik’s characterisation of Kuki attacks as acts of declaration of war. He said no community should declare war on another. He said Manipur needs de-escalation, not language that pushes two indigenous peoples into war. He said if there are killings, the remedy is investigation, arrest on evidence, and trial, not war on a whole community. He said Kukis too have been killed, displaced, and have seen their homes and churches burnt since May 2023. He said thousands remain in relief camps. He said selective justice is not justice.

On the Suspension of Operations agreement, Haokip responded to Zimik’s description of the SoO as a licence to kill and the main root cause of ethnic wars, and his demand for its immediate abrogation. Haokip said this was false. He said the SoO was signed between the Government of India, the Government of Manipur and Kuki armed groups to bring armed groups into designated camps, stop violence, and create space for political dialogue. He said it was a peace mechanism, not a war mechanism. He said its ground rules are clear: cadres stay in designated camps, weapons are in joint custody, movement is restricted, and violations are monitored by the Joint Monitoring Group.

Retired IRS Officer D.P. Haokip Rejects Timothy Zimik’s Open Letter, Urges Govt To Uphold Peace Framework And Equal Justice In Manipur

File Photo: D.P. Haokip, IRS (Retd.), of K. Salbung, Churachandpur, who issued a rejoinder rejecting Timothy Zimik’s open letter on Manipur peace.

Haokip argued that if there are violations, the remedy is stronger monitoring, joint verification, and action against the individual violator, not destruction of the peace framework. He said Zimik’s own logic in another part of his letter defeats his case. According to Haokip, Zimik says there was never any conflict between Kuki groups and security forces, that they collaborate, and therefore SoO was never required. Haokip said if that is true, SoO cannot simultaneously be a weapon of war. He said abrogating SoO will not bring peace. He said it will destroy the only mechanism that keeps armed groups in camps and under monitoring, and push Manipur back to uncontrolled violence.

On the Mt. Sinai camp, Haokip addressed Zimik’s citation of the October 19, 2026 operation at the Mt. Sinai SoO camp – where, according to Zimik, 17 non-SoO persons and only one registered cadre were found against a sanctioned strength of 159 – to claim that all 14 camps are fake. Haokip said one incident does not prove a conspiracy across all camps. He said it proves the need for transparent inquiry. He asked for the full official report to be published. He asked who was arrested, what weapons were seized, and what was the finding of the Joint Monitoring Group. He said he welcomes joint verification of all SoO camps – transparently, lawfully, and with equal verification of armed groups of all communities. He said let facts speak, not rumour.

On the Assam Rifles and the Government of India, Haokip responded to Zimik’s claim that the Assam Rifles and Kuki armed groups are business partners, and that the Government of India has as State Policy decided to assist Kuki illegal aliens to kill Nagas and Meiteis and occupy their lands. Haokip called this a reckless attack on the integrity of the Government of India and its security forces. He said if Zimik has proof, he should produce it before a court or a Commission of Inquiry. He said if he has no proof, he must be held accountable for defaming a force that has lost its own personnel trying to keep peace in Manipur. He said Zimik cannot demand more military action on one hand and accuse the military of conspiracy on the other, and that his letter collapses on its own contradiction.

Retired IRS Officer D.P. Haokip Rejects Timothy Zimik’s Open Letter, Urges Govt To Uphold Peace Framework And Equal Justice In Manipur

File Photo: The 4-page rejoinder dated November 18, 2026, written by D.P. Haokip, IRS (Retd.), to the Chief Minister and Governor of Manipur, rejecting the open letter of K. Timothy Zimik

Haokip said there is no State Policy to help any community kill another. He said the policy of the Indian State is the Constitution – protection of all citizens equally. He argued that accusing the state of siding with one community undermines trust in institutions at a time when trust is most needed. He said the government must act on evidence and law, not on communal narratives, and must protect every village equally, regardless of which community lives there.

On illegal immigration, Haokip responded to Zimik’s repeated description of Kukis as illegal immigrants, illegal aliens and foreigners from Myanmar. He said he rejected this with contempt. He said Kukis are not foreigners in Manipur. He said they are an indigenous people of Manipur. He said illegal immigration must be dealt with by lawful means – border fencing, verification, NRC, due process – applicable to all. He said it must not be dealt with by branding an entire indigenous tribe as foreigners. He said Zimik’s formula is clear in his reading: first declare a people as foreigners, then declare them as terrorists, then demand the State disarm them, raid their villages, and remove them. He said this is the language of ethnic cleansing. He said we will not be silent while it is used against us.

Haokip then placed seven demands before the Chief Minister and the Governor. First, reject Zimik’s demand for one-sided military operations against Kuki villages. Second, ensure no operation is carried out on the basis of a communal list prepared by any community leader. Third, do not abrogate the SoO to satisfy communal pressure. Fourth, strengthen monitoring and joint verification, and act transparently against any individual violator from any group. Fifth, order an independent investigation into the November 13, 2026 New Heaven ambush and all killings since February 2026, covering victims of all communities.

Sixth, order an independent inquiry into all killings, arson, displacement and human rights violations since May 2023, covering all communities. Seventh, act against hate speech that brands an entire community as terrorists and foreigners. And finally, ensure the safety, return, rehabilitation and dignity of all displaced persons – Kuki, Naga and Meitei – and protect every village equally. Haokip said these demands are not for one community alone, but for a process that can restore confidence across communities.

In his conclusion, Haokip responded to Zimik’s warning that war will escalate if the government sides with the Kukis. Haokip said he holds the opposite view: war will escalate if the government sides with injustice and one-sided action. He said Manipur will not get peace by disarming one community, raiding one community’s villages, abrogating peace agreements, and calling one community foreigners and terrorists. He said Manipur will get peace only by truth, equal justice, protection of all indigenous peoples, and dialogue – not by war-mongering letters.

Haokip said the people he speaks for want to live in their ancestral villages with dignity. He said they want their children to study without fear. He said they will not accept being turned into the enemy of the State to satisfy one man’s communal agenda. He urged the Government of India and the Government of Manipur not to listen to hatred, but to listen to the Constitution. He said protect all, punish the guilty whoever they are, and do not punish an entire people. He closed by stating that he strongly, totally and unconditionally rejects the open letter dated November 15, 2026 of K. Timothy Zimik.

The rejoinder has since circulated widely on social media in Manipur, drawing attention because both authors are retired officers of the Indian Revenue Service. As of the time of reporting, there was no public response from Zimik to Haokip’s rejoinder, nor an official statement from the Chief Minister’s Office or the Governor’s office on the specific demands made. The issues raised – the SoO agreement, the investigation into the New Heaven killings, and the handling of hate speech and disarmament – remain subjects of public debate in the state.

Observers note that the exchange reflects a wider contest over narratives in Manipur since May 2023, with different communities presenting sharply different accounts of history, violence and the role of the state. Haokip’s letter seeks to frame the debate around due process, independent investigation and equal application of law, while Zimik’s letter, as summarised by Haokip, seeks stronger security action against Kuki villages and an end to the SoO framework. The government has not yet indicated whether it will accept Haokip’s call for independent inquiries or for strengthened joint monitoring of SoO camps.

For residents in Churachandpur and other affected districts, the immediate concern remains safety, return and rehabilitation. Haokip’s letter ends on that note, calling for protection of every village equally and for dignity for all displaced persons, irrespective of community. Whether the state government acts on the demands for independent investigation and equal protection will be watched closely in the coming days, as Manipur continues to search for a path from confrontation to dialogue.

KE Desk

Kukiland Express Desk is the official editorial team of Kukiland Express. We cover breaking news, world news, in-depth analysis, and stories of the Kuki people across the Chittagong Hill Tracts, Northeast India, and parts of Western Myanmar.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Retired IRS Officer D.P. Haokip Joins Congress in Delhi, Set to Contest from 59-Saikot

Auto Draft

New Delhi: In a significant political development for Churachandpur district, D.P. Haokip, retired Indian Revenue Service officer and intending candidate for 59-Saikot (ST) Assembly Constituency, officially joined the Indian National Congress on November 2, 2026, in New Delhi.

Haokip was accorded a grand reception by the party’s state and central leadership. The joining programme was organised under the supervision of Saptagiri Sankar Ulaka, MP and AICC In-charge for Manipur, in presence of Okram Ibobi Singh, President of Manipur Pradesh Congress Committee and former Chief Minister; K. Meghachandra Singh, CLP Leader; Victor Keishing and T. Manga Vaiphei, Working Presidents of MPCC; and Amir Hussain, General Secretary, MPCC.

The event also marked the return of Dr. Chaltolen Amo to the Congress fold. Party leaders stated that the joining of both leaders will strengthen the Congress organisation in Churachandpur and particularly in Saikot.

D.P. Haokip, known for his clean administrative record and disciplined service, retired after a long career in the IRS. His decision to join the Congress is being viewed by supporters as a move towards honest and people-centric leadership for Saikot, a constituency that has been demanding development, stability and good governance.

Following the joining ceremony, the Manipur Congress delegation met Rahul Gandhi, Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, and Mallikarjun Kharge, President of AICC, in New Delhi. The meeting reportedly discussed the current political situation in Manipur, organisational strengthening, and preparation for the upcoming 13th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election in 2027.

The development has generated enthusiasm among Congress workers in Saikot. Supporters who gathered after the news said Haokip’s entry brings new hope and could prove to be a turning point for the constituency in the next election.

KE Desk

Kukiland Express Desk is the official editorial team of Kukiland Express. We cover breaking news, world news, in-depth analysis, and stories of the Kuki people across the Chittagong Hill Tracts, Northeast India, and parts of Western Myanmar.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *